Menu 

Do I Need a Florida Debt Collection Defense Attorney?


January 8, 2025

If you’re accused of murder, you know you need to hire an attorney. But what if you just owe debts you can’t pay? When should you handle it yourself, and when do you need a Florida debt collection defense attorney?

When you are already overwhelmed with debt, you may hesitate to get legal help, because you are afraid of just adding to your debt. However, understanding consumer law is crucial for navigating debt collection issues and protecting yourself from unfair practices. In many situations, a lawyer can save you money and give you a lifeline to getting your life back on track. That doesn’t mean you always need the help of a lawyer. Let’s look at the factors you should consider.

Understanding Debt Collection and Your Rights

Debt collection is the process of pursuing payments of debts owed by individuals or businesses. Debt collectors, who may be working for a collection agency or as independent agents, often use various methods to recover these debts, including phone calls, letters, and even lawsuits. However, it’s crucial to know that debt collectors must adhere to federal law and state law, specifically the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) and Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act (FCCPA). These acts regulates their activities and prohibits unfair or deceptive practices.

As a consumer, you have several rights under the FDCPA and FCCPA. You can request validation of the debt, dispute the debt, and even ask debt collectors to stop contacting you. If a debt collector violates the FDCPA, you have the right to sue them. Understanding these rights is essential to protect yourself from unfair practices. If you’re being contacted by a debt collector, knowing how to respond and what steps to take can safeguard your rights and prevent further issues.

Do You Actually Owe the Debt to the Debt Collector?

The first thing to consider is whether or not you actually owe the money the debt collector claims. Ensuring the creditor has the legally required paperwork to validate the debt is crucial. If you do not owe it, and the creditor refuses to correct their records, it might be time to bring in an attorney before the situation escalates.

How Much Do You Owe?

worried, paying, bills

If you owe the money in question, you will want to consider the amount of the debt versus the legal costs of hiring an attorney even if you have a good defense to a lawsuit. Be sure to factor in the possibility that the debtor may ask the court to award interest, attorney fees and court costs. Interest and fees add up fast. A good debt collection defense attorney is likely to be much more effective in settling the debt for a lesser amount than you would be yourself. But if you only owe a small amount, you can easily pay off, you probably do not need a Florida debt collection defense lawyer.

Are You Judgment-Proof?

If a creditor takes you to court and gets a judgment against you, will they even be able to collect? Do you have a job, property or a bank account? These considers factor into whether you are “judgment-proof” (or more accurately, “collection-proof” because even someone who has protected assets can still have a judgment entered against them).

Additionally, keep in mind that even if you are collection-proof now, should your situation later improve, that judgment will still be hanging over your head for some time to come and may then be collectible.

It’s important to understand the concept of legal standing, which refers to the conditions under which creditors have the right to pursue legal action for outstanding debts. If a creditor fails to meet specific legal requirements, such as filing in the correct court or timing of the debt, they may lack the legal standing to collect, which can significantly impact your defense strategy.

Talk to a good Florida debt collection attorney to determine if you are judgment-proof and whether it makes sense for you to hire a lawyer. Then make up your own mind.

Are You Being Sued?

ai generated, courtroom, court

Once you are facing a lawsuit, the urgency of your situation increases. Debt collection agencies often file lawsuits, and in Florida, you have only 20 days to file an answer to a complaint with the court (for county court and circuit court cases). If you do not respond to a debt collection complaint, the court will likely order a default judgment against you in the amount the plaintiff creditor requests. The total including costs, interests and fees can easily be much more than you owe if you take no steps to defend yourself. If you do respond, you still need to show up in court for your hearing.

Once the plaintiff has a judgment against you, they can potentially begin action to garnish your wages, seize your bank accounts and put a lien on real property (subject to various conditions). They can potentially subpoena records from your mortgage lender, bank and other loan holders through a process called “discovery in aid of execution”. They can also subpoena you to go back to court to answer questions about your finances. If you don’t show up, you may be charged with contempt of court. If you are being sued and you cannot settle your case with terms you can handle, you need a good Florida debt collection defense attorney.

Signs You Need a Debt Collection Defense Attorney

If you’re being contacted by a debt collector, it’s important to recognize when it’s time to seek the help of a debt collection attorney. Here are some signs that you may need professional legal assistance:

  • You’re being sued by a debt collector.
  • You’re receiving harassing phone calls or letters from a debt collector.
  • You’re unsure about the validity of the debt or the amount owed.
  • You’re being asked to pay a debt that you don’t owe.
  • You’re experiencing financial difficulties and need help negotiating with debt collectors.

A debt collection attorney can help you understand your rights and options, and provide representation in court if necessary. They can also assist in negotiating with debt collectors to work out a payment plan that’s manageable for you. If any of these situations apply to you, it might be time to consult with a debt collection attorney.

You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know

Debt collection defense attorneys know the intricacies of defenses and counterclaims that may be unfamiliar to you. After all, they do it for a living. Consulting with a law firm can provide valuable legal advice and support, helping you navigate your debt situation effectively. This is why it’s worthwhile to hire an attorney if you have a substantial amount on the line. At the very least, you should sit down with an attorney for an initial consultation to discuss your options. Let’s take a look at just some of the possible defenses and counterclaims that can mitigate your situation even if you do owe the debt.

Possible Defenses

A defense is an argument for why you are not responsible for the debt or why the creditor should legally be unable to collect.

Here are a few common defenses:

  • Debt collection has exceeded the statute of limitations, the time in which the creditor can legally sue
  • The creditor filed in the wrong court
  • The creditor cannot produce the documentation necessary to prove you owe the debt. This happens a lot when a debt buyer brings a lawsuit.
  • The creditor does not have the legally required paperwork to file the suit, which can be a strong basis for your defense.

Possible Counterclaims

A counterclaim is a complaint that you file against the creditor who has sued you. Consumer law provides protections that can form the basis of counterclaims. Federal and Florida consumer laws offer protection from unfair debt collection practices and penalize collection agencies that violate them. If you win your counterclaim, you may still owe the debt but may be able to collect money damages. A threat of a strong counterclaim may sometimes compel a creditor to refrain from suing or withdraw its lawsuit.

Just some of the possible counterclaims include:

  • Illegal harassment or abuse such as a collection agent calling as friends, employers or other third parties about your debt (except in very limited circumstances such as help in locating you). It is also harassment for a collection agent to call constantly or at odd hours
  • Deception such as a collection agent misrepresenting themselves as a government official or credit reporting agency employee
  • Unfair practices such as making unsubstantiated legal threats
  • Giving false information about you to third parties
  • Misleading correspondence such as sending you letters that appear to be from a government agency

How Much Will It Cost You to Hire a Florida Debt Collection Defense Attorney for Legal Representation?

Many Florida debt collection defense attorneys offer an initial free consultation where you can get answers to your questions and learn what it will cost you to proceed with their legal representation. Possibilities include a flat fee, an hourly fee or a percentage of what the attorney saves you. In some instances, the court may order your creditor to pay your attorney fees.

One of the reasons to hire an attorney is to save money rather than spend more. Understanding legal costs is crucial, as they can significantly impact your decision to hire an attorney. You are doing yourself a great disservice not to speak with an attorney about the options available to you and the cost of legal representation.

Choosing the Right Debt Collection Defense Attorney

Selecting the right debt collection defense attorney can feel overwhelming, but it’s crucial to find someone with the right experience and expertise. Here are some tips to help you choose the best attorney for your needs:

  • Look for an attorney with extensive experience in debt collection law and familiarity with the FDCPA.
  • Check the attorney’s reputation online and seek referrals from friends or family members.
  • Ensure the attorney is licensed to practice law in your state and has a good standing with the state bar association.
  • Discuss the attorney’s fees and understand how they will be paid.
  • Make sure the attorney is willing to communicate with you regularly and keep you informed about the progress of your case.

By following these tips, you can find a debt collection attorney who will provide you with the best possible representation and help you navigate the complexities of debt collection law.

What to Expect from a Debt Collection Attorney

When you work with a debt collection attorney, you can expect expert legal advice and representation tailored to your situation. Here are some of the services a debt collection attorney can provide:

  • A thorough review of your case and an explanation of your rights and options.
  • Representation in court, if necessary.
  • Negotiation with debt collectors to work out a payment plan that’s affordable for you.
  • Assistance with disputing debts and requesting validation of debts.
  • Protection from harassing phone calls and letters from debt collectors.

A debt collection attorney can also help you understand the debt collection process and the laws that govern it. They will guide you on how to respond to debt collectors and protect your rights. It’s important to remember that debt collection attorneys charge fees for their services, so you should discuss their fees and payment structure before hiring one. However, the cost of hiring a debt collection attorney can be a worthwhile investment if you’re facing a debt collection lawsuit or need help negotiating with debt collectors.

Should You Consider Bankruptcy?

If you have a significant amount of debt, in some cases declaring bankruptcy may be preferable to defending against debt collection lawsuits, particularly if you have multiple creditors. Therefore, you will want to speak with an attorney who is experienced both in debt collection defense and bankruptcy.

Call Us If You Need a Florida Debt Collection Defense Attorney

Do you need a Florida debt collection defense lawyer? Call us so we can advise you of your options.

If you are being sued or if a debt collector is threatening to sue you, immediately contact Ziegler Diamond Law: Debt Fighters for a free consultation by submitting this form. Or just call us directly at (727) 538-4188 in Clearwater, (813) 225-3111 in Tampa or (352) 600-1326 in Mt. Dora. There is no time to waste!

Ziegler Diamond Law: Debt Fighters, provides effective legal services to consumers throughout Florida who are facing home foreclosure, unmanageable debts, debt collector harassment, or other debt-related problems.

author avatar
Michael Ziegler Managing Partner
Michael Ziegler is the managing partner of Ziegler Diamond Law, serving consumers throughout Florida. With a focus on consumer protection, Michael helps clients navigate bankruptcy, defend against debt collection lawsuits, and address credit reporting errors. Known for his strategic approach and dedication to empowering individuals to regain financial control, Michael also chairs the Clearwater Bar Association's Small Firm section. Outside the office, he enjoys camping with his family and pursuing real estate ventures.

Share this Article